Home › Blog › How Do I Pick the Right Health Insurance Plan? (2027 Step-by-Step)

How Do I Pick the Right Health Insurance Plan? (2027 Step-by-Step)

By Martin Elefant · Licensed insurance agent · Updated November 2026 · 7 min read

Picking a plan gets easier when you stop comparing brochures and start comparing what you'd actually spend in a normal year and in a bad year. Here's the process I use with clients.

Step 1: Figure out which markets you can use

Start with eligibility, because it narrows everything else:

  • Do you have an employer offer? If it's affordable, it usually blocks a marketplace subsidy.
  • What's your expected 2027 household income? Between 100% and 400% of the poverty level ($15,960–$63,840 for one person) you can get a premium tax credit. See the subsidy income limits.
  • Whether Medicaid covers low-income adults depends on your state. In the 40 states plus D.C. that expanded Medicaid, adults earning up to 138% of the poverty level (about $22,025 for one person) can generally qualify. In the states that didn't expand, including Texas, Florida, Georgia, Tennessee, South Carolina and Alabama, many adults below the poverty line fall into a coverage gap with no Medicaid and no marketplace subsidy.
  • Are you generally healthy? If so, private underwritten plans are also on the table. Private plan options also vary by state. A few states, including New York, New Jersey, California and Massachusetts, restrict non-ACA plans heavily, so the choices there are narrower.

Step 2: List what you need covered

Write down your doctors, the hospital you'd use, every prescription, and anything planned for 2027: a baby, a surgery, therapy, physical therapy.

Step 3: Filter by network

Cross off any plan that doesn't include your must-have doctors and hospital. This step eliminates more plans than any other.

Step 4: Estimate your total cost two ways

For each remaining plan, add up:

  • A normal year: 12 months of premium, plus the copays or deductible spending you'd expect for your usual visits and drugs.
  • A bad year: 12 months of premium plus the full out-of-pocket maximum (up to $12,000 for one person in 2027).

The best plan is usually the one with a good normal-year number and a bad-year number you could survive.

Step 5: Check the fine print

Read the Summary of Benefits and Coverage for prior authorization rules, exclusions, and whether office visits and generics have copays before the deductible.

Step 6: Enroll on time

On HealthCare.gov, open enrollment for 2027 coverage runs from November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027, and you need to pick a plan by December 15, 2026 for coverage that starts January 1. States that run their own exchange set their own dates: California, New Jersey and New York run to January 31, Massachusetts to January 23, and Virginia to January 29. Private plans can start the 1st of any month.

A quick example

A 45-year-old earning $70,000 with no subsidy compares a bronze plan at $560 a month ($12,000 max) with a gold plan at $790 a month ($5,000 max). Normal year with a few visits: bronze is about $7,000, gold about $9,600. Bad year: bronze is about $18,700, gold about $14,500. If she has savings and is healthy, bronze wins most years; if she expects surgery, gold does. (Prices are illustrative; yours depend on age and ZIP.)

Related: what to look for in a policy and questions to ask before you sign up. Or let us run the numbers for your ZIP code.

Frequently asked questions

How do I choose a health insurance plan?

Confirm which markets you qualify for, list your doctors and drugs, filter plans by network, then compare total yearly cost in a normal year and a worst-case year.

Should I choose bronze, silver or gold?

Bronze has the lowest premium and highest costs when you use care; gold is the reverse. Silver matters most if your income qualifies you for cost-sharing reductions, which only come with silver plans.

When can I enroll in a 2027 plan?

During open enrollment: November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027 on HealthCare.gov (later in some state exchanges). Private underwritten plans can start the 1st of any month.

Keep reading

ME
Martin Elefant
Licensed insurance agent · NPN 20765405 · Lyons Life LLC · Self-Employed Private Health

See your real options

Both markets, one call. Or call (561) 264-7827.

Check My Options →
Check My Options →